7300 Dorset Ave, St. Louis, MO 63130Mon–Fri 8–6 · Sat 8–3 · 314-820-0865

Matching Mortar on Historic St. Louis Brick: Lime, Cement and Getting It Right

St. Louis is one of the great brick cities in America. Keeping that brick healthy depends on something most people never notice: the mortar between it.

On historic St. Louis brick, repointing mortar should be softer and more breathable than the brick and no harder than the original mortar, which on most older buildings was rich in lime. Gateway City Tuckpointing matches new mortar to the color, texture and joint profile of the original so repairs protect the brick and blend in.

A Little St. Louis Brick History

St. Louis sits on unusually good clay. A belt of high-quality fire clay runs through the Cheltenham area south of today's Forest Park, along Manchester Road and the River Des Peres. Clay mining there began in the 1850s and continued into the 1940s, drawing Irish, Italian and German workers and helping shape neighborhoods like Dogtown and The Hill. Brickyards were already large before then; local histories report the city's yards were producing more than 20 million bricks a year by 1839.

Then came the Great Fire of 1849, which started on the steamboat White Cloud and burned a large part of the riverfront city. In its aftermath the city passed an ordinance forbidding new wooden buildings, and St. Louis became even more of a brick town. By the late 1800s the region was home to dozens of brick and clay manufacturers, and the red brick from those kilns built the flats, rowhouses, churches and storefronts that still define the city and inner suburbs.

That history matters for repair work. Much of the brick on St. Louis buildings is well over a century old, and so is the mortar holding it together.

Lime Mortar vs. Portland Cement Mortar

For most of the 1800s, mortar was made from lime and sand. Lime mortar is relatively soft, flexible and vapor-permeable: moisture can pass through it and evaporate out of the wall. Portland cement began to appear in mortar in the late 1800s, first as a small additive to speed setting, and by around the 1930s most masons were mixing cement and lime together. Modern mortars with a high cement content are much harder and less permeable than the old lime mixes.

Lime-rich (historic-type) mortarHigh-cement modern mortar
HardnessSofter than most old brickOften harder than old brick
BreathabilityLets moisture escape through the jointsTraps moisture in the brick
MovementFlexes with seasonal movementRigid; stress goes into the brick
When it failsThe joint wears and can be repointedThe brick face cracks or spalls
Best usePre-1930s brick and soft stoneModern hard brick and block designed for it

Why Hard Mortar Damages Old Brick

A masonry wall is designed so that the mortar is the sacrificial part. When water gets into the wall, it should leave through the joints, and when the wall expands and contracts with the seasons, the joints should take the stress. That's why national preservation guidance, including the National Park Service's Preservation Brief 2 on repointing, says new mortar should be softer or more permeable than the masonry units and no harder or less permeable than the historic mortar.

Put a hard cement joint next to older, softer brick and the roles reverse. Moisture can't escape through the joint, so it moves through the brick instead. In a St. Louis winter, that water freezes in the brick faces, and the edges and faces of the brick start to crack and pop off. The hard joints stay put while the brick around them crumbles. It's one of the most common kinds of damage we see on older houses that were "repaired" with whatever mortar was handy.

If your wall already has hard gray patches, they can often be carefully cut out and replaced with a compatible mix, and badly spalled bricks can be replaced. See brick, stone and block repair.

Red brick arches over windows on an older St. Louis building
Arches, corbels and decorative brick on older St. Louis buildings call for careful, matched repointing.

What a Good Mortar Match Involves

Strength and composition

The starting point is a mix that is compatible with the brick. On most pre-1930s St. Louis buildings, that means a lime-rich mortar rather than a straight cement mix. The exact proportions depend on the brick, the original mortar and how exposed the wall is.

Sand

Sand does most of the work in matching appearance. Its color, grain size and texture show on the face of the joint once it weathers. Matching the sand to the original is often more important than the binder for getting the look right.

Color

Old St. Louis mortar ranges from buff and tan to gray, and joints darken or lighten with age and dirt. We compare test batches against clean, freshly exposed original mortar, since the color of the mix changes as it cures and dries.

Joint profile and width

How the joint is finished, whether flush, concave, struck, raked or a decorative profile, changes how the wall reads from the street. New joints should match the original width and profile. Widening joints with a grinder or smearing mortar over the brick edges makes repairs obvious and changes the character of the facade.

Technique

Matching also depends on doing the work right: cutting old mortar out to a consistent depth without chipping brick edges, packing new mortar in layers, and tooling joints at the right moment as they set. Our tuckpointing page walks through the full process.

Historic home or building? We match mortar to color, texture and joint profile on every job. Call 314-820-0865 for a free estimate.

Historic Districts Around St. Louis

Matching isn't only about protecting the brick. Properties in local historic districts often have review requirements for visible exterior work. In University City, the Historic Preservation Commission reviews certain exterior work on landmarks and in historic districts, and mortar color and joint profile are part of what a good repair has to get right. Neighborhoods across St. Louis City and the Central West End have their own historic district rules too. Check with your city before major visible work. For U City specifics, see our post on occupancy inspections and masonry.

Chimneys and Foundations

The same rules apply below and above the main walls. Old limestone foundations under St. Louis homes were usually laid in soft lime mortar, and repointing them with hard cement can trap moisture in the stone. See masonry foundation repair. Chimneys need durable joints because of their exposure, but the mix still has to be compatible with the chimney's brick. Our chimney repair work follows the same matching approach.

Questions to Ask Any Mason

  • What mortar mix will you use, and why does it suit this brick?
  • How will you match the color and sand of the existing joints?
  • What joint profile will you finish with?
  • How deep will you cut out the old mortar?

A mason who works on older buildings should be able to answer all four without hesitation. For more on timing, see how long tuckpointing lasts.

Questions

Historic Mortar FAQs

What kind of mortar is in old St. Louis brick homes?

Most buildings from before about the 1930s were laid with lime-rich mortar. Portland cement was added in growing amounts from the late 1800s on, so the exact mix varies with the age of the building.

Why is hard cement mortar bad for old brick?

Mortar harder and less permeable than the brick traps moisture and pushes seasonal stress into the brick. In freeze and thaw weather, the brick faces crack and spall instead of the joints wearing as intended.

Can new mortar match the color of my old mortar?

Usually, yes. Color comes mostly from the sand and binder, so we compare test batches with clean original mortar and adjust until the cured joint blends with the wall.

Can hard cement patches be removed?

In many cases they can be carefully cut out and replaced with a compatible mortar. Bricks already damaged by hard patches may need to be replaced with close matches.

Do historic districts require a specific mortar?

Rules vary by city. Historic commissions generally expect repairs that match the original appearance. Check with your city before major visible work on a landmark or in a historic district.

Repointing an older brick building?

Matched mortar, careful work, free estimates.

314-820-0865
Call NowFree Estimate